Friday, September 28, 2012

Fallacy Research #2: Circular Reasoning


By: Melisa Bell
      The fallacy circular reasoning occurs when the concBylusion of an argument is essentially the same as tone of the premises in a the argument. This may also called "begging the argument". A tip to avoid this fallacy is to bring up new points and details in your writing, but make sure they reflect the current topic being discussed.





Reading like a Writer & Developing the Refections


By: Melisa Bell

Staples describes the person he encountered as a woman, white, well dressed, in her twenties. When she first caught sight of him she casted back a worried glance and picked up her pace after a few more glimpses. She then began to run and within seconds she disappeared into the cross street. Staples describes himself as a youngish black man, six feet two inches with a beard and billowing hair, both hands shoved into his pockets of a bulky military jacket. He refers to himself as a broad. Although Staples has no intentions of approaching the young woman as he is walking, the woman is still fearful of him. A detail that is added to make this occasion especially vivid and dramatic is the way Staples describes himself (billowing hair, both hands shoved in the pockets of his military jacket). Another detail that is added is the discreet, inflammatory distance between us. Staples uses the details of the event to tell his story by dramatically describing the situation. This lets the reader really understand and picture the situation in their head.

Some of the precautions that Staples takes to make himself seem less threatening to the general public is to to move about with care, exchange jeans for business clothes, let people clear away from areas before entering, act very calm and extremely congenial when pulled over by the police, and whistle Beethoven and Vivaldi melodies. Staples uses examples to explain to his readers what exactly he’s talking about. He gives examples of how he takes precautions when dealing with the public.

Black Men and Public Space

Maintaining Topical Coherence:
By: Alan Casteneda


Staples, helps maintain to topical coherence by repeating a key work in many ways, "fear." It is used in various ways though this essay. Maybe because back in the 1970's and 80's being a black man was difficult. In his essay for example, he was writing an article for a magazine and when he was in the building he was mistaken for a burglar. He also states that people would cross the street rather than pass by him at night time. He learned to deal with it and picked up whistling some tunes. He thought that maybe whistling would help him out since what burglar would whistle while committing a crime?


Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Hasty Generalization Fallacy

By: Shauna Sannella

Fallacy - A mistaken belief; one based on unsound argument


A hasty generalization is when a person draws an immediate conclusion from a short observation period. It's basically looking at one part of a whole and forming your argument from that. Sometimes you get lucky and that one part that you looked at is correct, but most of the time all of the missed information renders your argument invalid. Hasty generalization fallacies can be avoided by researching your topic in full and making sure that you present both sides of an argument. 

Don't be stubborn or biased in your writing :)

http://vancouvermoose.wordpress.com/2009/05/07/vast/




Wednesday, September 12, 2012

"Soup" and "I'm Not Leaving Until I Eat This Thing"

By: Alan Casteneda


     These are stories about a man and his food company. Mr Yeganeh in Soup also described as the soup natzi in one of the Seinfield episoides. Also Lionel Dufour from Farm Fresh. Soup takes place in a large city, maybe the largest in the U.S. While I'm Not Leaving Until I Eat This Thing, takes place in a southern state of Louisiana. Mr Yagenah runs his business at a very high standard, and strictly business.   He wants to make his customers happy, but believes the customer is always wrong and he is always right. One way in making sure the customer is always happy is by keeping the line moving, no conversation between the customer and him unless it is the order. His restaurant always uses fresh ingredients and holds his employees to high standards. Does not hesitate to fire one if he thinks they are wrong. He loves his soups! He would not sell anything he thought to be disgusting or not up to par.

     Lionel Dufour, has been in the meat business since he was six years old. He started out helping his father make deliveries.  He runs a bigger business than Mr. Yeganeh. His plant delivers sausage, pig feet, and pig lips. He him self does not manually work in the plant, he has hired six women to work in the production line. Unlike Mr. Yeganeh for as long as he has worked around meat, he has not tried the pig lips. That is until he is at the bar and has had a few drinks. He order pig lips, when they were served he did not know what to do with them. I do not believe he enjoys his own product.

     Overall, These two business owner despite the differences on how they run and view their business. They are very successful. Both have been around for many years.


Analysis To Chapters 4 & 5

By: Shauna Sannella

The chapters we read were about how to write an effective college essay and all the different components that are distributed into the process. Chapter 4 was about planning/drafting your essay, and the 5 factors that you must understand to fully meet the criteria of an essay. They are: purpose, audience, topic, tone, context and genre. You are writing for a reason(purpose), to a specific group of people(audience), about a topic, in a specific way(tone, context, genre). There are many different ways of gathering ideas for your essay including, brainstorming, freewriting and many more. To keep these ideas organized while writing make sure to use good transitional words, and repeat certain phrases and words in a way that focuses your essay on the main purpose. You should begin and end your essay with a thesis statement that makes an engaging, relevant, arguable claim, while the body should be you making your readers understand and agree with the claim you made. If you actually use and practice all these techniques in your writing, you are almost guaranteed the "A" grade that you desire!

I believe strongly in the message these chapters are trying to convey. You must give each and every aspect of your writing plenty of thought, because each piece plays an important part in how clear and powerful your essay comes off to the reader. When I write, I'm constantly changing my word choice and sentence structure because the paragraphs flow better if they sound like someone talking. Writing is also a little easier if you first identify the purpose, audience, topic, tone, context and genre that you are writing about.



Monday, September 10, 2012

Comparing and Contrasting

By

In the “Soup” essay, the business philosophy is that “The customer is always wrong, and I [Mr. Yeganeh] am always right.” This is very different from the “I’m not leaving” essay, because their business philosophy is not unlike the original quote, “The customer is always right.” Mr. Yeganeh doesn’t care if the customer dislikes his attitude or the way his store is run. He knows his soup is so delicious and one of a kind that people will always come back and his store will always be in business. The meat industry on the other hand is much larger than the soup industry. If a customer is not satisfied with the way Mr. Dufour runs his store, they will simply take their business elsewhere and eventually Mr. Dufour will go out of business. 


http://www.freakonomics.com/2007/11/21/eula-wars-the-customer-is-always-right-to-lodge-a-protest/

Friday, September 7, 2012

Talking About Visuals

By: Melisa Bell

      In the begining, Edge seems to be having a great time at Farm Fresh. He meets Lionel, a 50-year-old father that shows him around the place. Edge seems pretty confortable with the place, until he is pressed with the opportunity of trying one of the pig lips. After reading about his experience at the bar, the reader realizes that the lips the farm produces must have an acquired taste, or Edge just doesn't seem to enjoy the pig lip.

     Edge is seen as a spectator and participant in his observational essay. Edge at first, explains how he is being a "spectator" in a sense, at the farm. Edge becomes a participant when he decides to try the lip. He describes in great detail about his experience. Both of these roles contribute to the effectiveness of his observational essay because they provide the reader with not only one, but two views about the farm. These described experiences provide the reader with two vivid pictures of Edge's experience on the farm.

     Overall, one would agree that this essay is very well put together. It provides the reader with a picture in their head of each scene that Edge describes. From walking around at Farm Fresh, to actually trying the pig lip, Edge does an outstanding job of keeping the reader not only entertained, but all-knowing about the scenario he experienced.

PIG LIP 123.jpg

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Whatever Scalzi Blog Analysis

By: 


Personal Connection: 8. His posts were interesting to read and we learned some new things when scrolling through. His humor was enjoyable and fun.
Hook: 7. The first sentence is usually something short and funny. It makes you wanna keep reading!
Visually Pleasing: 8. Some text is bold and and some is italic which gives the text personality. We took two points away for lack of color.
Multimedia: 5. There are no videos on the blog on the recent posts. There are some funny pictures that relate to his life, and they make you want to know more about him.
Popularity: 10. Every post has 20+ comments on it. Some of them have as many as 100-150 comments, so you can tell plenty of people follow his blog!
Voice/Timeliness/Frequency: 10. He blogs every other day it seems, and his voice is fun to read and easy to relate to.
Organized/Consistacy: 10. His blog is very organized, he doesn't have links for random stuff all over the page. You can clearly see each post in order and determine which post is which.
Length/Fits the Purpose: 10. He keeps to the point and doesn't wander off topic in his writing. He keeps you entertained by talking about things that are relevant.

Well there you have it! Enjoy!