Friday, October 19, 2012

Reading Response

By: Melisa Bell
  
From the section I read in Writing Matters, I learned a lot about fallacies, claims of judgment and value, effective arguments, and logic. I learned that claims of fact are statements that are either true or false. Claims of judgment are someone’s opinion. Claims of value are statements of belief. This is something that individuals or groups hold true. They are based on morals, religious, or aesthetic values. There are two types of effective arguments that appeal to readers’ intellect and (sometimes) their emotions. These are logos and pathos. Logos is evidence that is rational and relevant. It appeals to readers by engaging their logical power. On the other hand, pathos is evidence to support a claim by stirring the audience’s emotions in an effort to get their sympathy, and making them agree with the claim. Inductive logic is when a writer cites a particular example or specific instance to draw a conclusion or claim. Counterevidence is evidence that undetermined your claim. It can weaken a conclusion reached inductively. Deductive logic starts from a general premise to draw conclusions about specific instances.
           
            The hasty generalization is when a writer jumps to conclusions. The generalization applies to a claim to all cases when it actually only applies to a few or maybe none of the cases.  The false analogy generalization draws a connection between two items or events that have few relevant common characteristics.  The bandwagon appeal generalization implies that the major opinion is the right opinion and invites you to climb aboard. The begging the questions generalization (circular reasoning) is when the writer begins with what he or she is trying to end up with. The non-sequitur generalization draws a conclusion from a premise that does not follow logically. The post hoc, ergo propter hoc generalization is when the speaker wrongly assumes that the first event caused the second. The either or generalization is misleading and only provides two sides of the argument. The ad hominem generalization attempts to undermine an opposing viewpoint by criticizing the motives or character of the individual holding the position, without connecting character flaws to the issue.


No comments:

Post a Comment