
http://nerdsinbabeland.com/
Organized
I think it is fairly well organized. They have their most recent posts to the side on the top, the post themselves are orderly, the follow button is obvious, there is a convenient "go to top" button, they've attached their twitter and RSS feeds and there are navigation buttons at the top. Everything has a place and is easy enough to find. Even on the mobile version it is very organized and easy to navigate. 10
Consistency
The site is consistently organized. Nothing is running off the page or overlapping something else so that we can't see it. All the different places to go on the side and top stay in their place. It just looks very nice. 10
Personal connection
I absolutely love the post with the shoes!! I need those shoes. I would love to read some of those books too. I'm not sure I quite classify as a nerd, but maybe a nerd in training? I think this blog is quite relevant to my interests. http://www.etsy.com/shop/aishavoya seriously. 9
Writer’s hook/voice
I think there are two contributors on a regular basis and a guest writer every once-in-a-while. All of them are, of course, good writers.
MissLissa is into the facts and numbers of her review which I think adds a nice little oh-cool-i-didn't-know-that effect. She knows a lot about what she is writing about and I like that. Otherwise it would be like me writing about Saga, I had never even heard of it before. It sounds cool though. 10
Prof. Jenn's writing is playful and jam-packed with lots of fun words. Reading her reviews sounds like she is actually talking to you and telling you exactly how she feels about it. Very nice. I like that there is almost always a bottom line. 10
Visually pleasing/Multimedia
There is always at least one picture for each review. For comics they usually have the cover and an interesting inside page for your viewing pleasure. They don't have movie clips for the tv series reviews, but that's probably because that would be way too much of a spoiler. SPOILERS! I think it's all great. The headings (book review: blah, Supernatural, ect.) are nice so we know what exactly they are talking about and can scroll through and find what we're looking for. The website header is interesting and accurate. There are links/ "rabbit holes" which are always fun. The mobile version has different colored numbers for each month and the posts drop down to save space. If one enjoys the computer view better that is an option on your phone. 10
Popularity
Irrelevant. Their blog is beautiful and wonderful and there could be people (ehhem, me) who look at it and thoroughly enjoy it, but do not comment or follow.
Timeliness/frequency
The mobile version has the actual post dates of each post. However, the computer version has the archive type thing on the side with the most recent posts makes me believe they post monthly, but it's not a consistent number of posts and as you get closer to the top it's "a month ago" "two weeks ago" "four days ago" , so It seems as though they just post whenever they feel like it. That's great for them because that way they don't feel obligated to slave over the blog to make sure it's consistent since that's a bit of a hassle. However, it kinda sucks for the followers because they don't know when they'll see something new. The anticipation could be fun though. 7
Length fits purpose
Yes. Some of the posts are more than the whole page long wich seems like a bit much to me, but they just have a lot to say and that's okay. There was one post about a character in walking dead that I wasn't sure about. It seemed to me that it just had a picture and a bunch of bolded names. I don't know, maybe it's relevant, I've only seen one episode of that show. For the most part the post are a good, non-repetitive length. 9
P.S. sorry I took so long...
No comments:
Post a Comment